best wood for carving

Best Wood for Carving and Whittling

Best Wood for Carving and Whittling: A Comprehensive Guide

The best wood for whittling that’s readily available is basswood. Basswood is soft, and not much force is needed when slicing it with a sharp whittling knife. This makes it very ideal for whittling. Lets get into more detail on basswood and other great woods for carving and whittling!

Understanding the Best Wood for Carving and Whittling

When it comes to whittling and carving, the type of wood you use can make a big difference in the outcome of your project. In this article, I will discuss some of the key factors to consider when choosing the best wood for whittling and carving.

Hard Wood vs Soft Wood for Carving

One of the first things to consider when choosing a wood for whittling or carving is whether it is a hard wood or a soft wood.  Fundamentally, softwoods are from coniferous trees, or evergreens.  Hardwoods are those from deciduous trees, or trees that drop their leaves each autumn.  However, there are several hardwoods that are quite soft, and there are several softwoods that can be harder and more durable.

Hard woods are denser and more durable than soft woods, which means they can be more difficult to carve but will hold up better over time. Soft woods, on the other hand, are easier to carve but may not be as durable and are prone to scratching or denting.

Understanding the Janka Hardness Scale

To help you determine the hardness of different woods, you can refer to the Janka hardness scale. This scale measures the amount of force required to embed a steel ball halfway into a piece of wood. The higher the Janka Hardness rating, the harder the wood.

Some of the most popular woods for whittling and carving, such as basswood and butternut, are relatively soft and have low Janka ratings. Other woods, such as oak and maple, are much harder and have higher Janka ratings.  For example, basswood has a Janka Hardness rating of 410 lbf, white oak has a Janka Hardness of 1360 lbf, and ironwood has a Janka Hardness rating of, an eye-popping, 3260 lbf.

Grain Patterns in the Best Wood for Carving

Another important factor to consider when choosing the best wood for carving and whittling is the grain pattern. Straight grain woods, such as basswood and butternut, are ideal for carving because they are easy to work with and have a consistent texture.

Woods with pronounced grains, such as oak, curly maple and ash, can be more difficult to carve because the grain can be unpredictable. Close-grained woods, such as cherry and walnut, can be more challenging to carve but yield beautiful results due to their fine texture and beautiful grain patterns.

Popular Woods for Whittling and Carving

Whittling and carving are great hobbies that require the right type of wood for best results. I will introduce you to some popular woods that are a good choice for whittling and carving. These woods are easy to work with and popular amongst wood carvers due to their fine and uniform wood grain, and generally wide spread availability.

Basswood (Lime Wood)

Basswood is the most popular wood for whittling and carving, and in my opinion is the best wood for carving, and especially for new carvers. It is soft and easy to carve with hand tools. The grain of Basswood is fine, and it is less likely to chip or split compared with other carving woods. Basswood is also readily available in most craft stores, or even some of the big box home improvement stores.  As previously mentioned, I highly recommend basswood for both beginners and seasoned woodcarvers.

best wood for carving

Cherry Wood

Cherry wood is another great wood for whittling and carving. It is a hardwood that is hard, yet fair, to carve and has a beautiful reddish-brown color. Cherry wood is also easy to sand and finish, making it a favorite wood among woodworkers.

Balsa Wood

Balsa wood is a very soft and lightweight wood making it the easiest wood to carve. It is a good wood for beginners because it is easy to work with and does not require much force when carving. Balsa wood is also widely available and can be found in most craft stores.  Balsa wood is so soft that the wood fibers can easily tear if not using very sharp tools and knives.

Maple Wood

Maple wood is a hardwood that is great for carving. There are two types of maple wood: hard maple and soft maple, along with several more unique varieties – curly maple, and tiger-eye maple. Hard maple (Janka 1450 lbf) is more difficult to work with because it is denser and harder than soft maple. Soft maple (Janka 700 lbf), on the other hand, is easier to carve and is a great choice for beginners.

White Pine

White pine is a softwood that is easy to carve and is great for beginners. It is a lightweight wood that is easy to work with and does not require much force when carving. White pine is also widely available and can be found in most craft stores and lumber yards.  White pine has a tendency to split if you attempt to take off too much wood in one pass, so remember to use shallow cuts.

Choosing the Right Wood for Your Carving Project

When it comes to whittling and carving, choosing the right wood is essential. The wood you select will determine the quality of your finished product, so it’s important to choose wisely. Here are some considerations to keep in mind when selecting the right wood for your project.

Considerations for Hand Tools

If you’re using hand tools, you’ll want to choose a wood that is easy to carve and won’t cause too much strain on your hands. Basswood is a great choice for beginners and experienced whittlers alike. It’s soft and easy to slice and cut with a knife, and its fine grain makes it less likely to chip or split compared to other carving woods. Other good options for hand carving include Butternut, Pine, and Cedar.

Considerations for Power Tools

If you’re using power tools like a power carver, angle grinder, or rotary tool, you’ll want to choose a wood that is dense and strong enough to withstand the force of the tools. Hardwoods like Cherry, Walnut, and Oak are great choices for power carving. They are strong and dense, which makes them ideal for relief carving and chip carving.

Choosing Wood for Spoon Carving

If you’re interested in carving spoons or other kitchen utensils, you’ll want to choose a wood that is both strong and safe for food use. Hardwoods like Cherry, Walnut, and Maple are great choices for spoon carving. They are strong enough to withstand the rigors of daily use, and they are safe for food use when properly finished with food-grade oil.

When selecting the right wood for your project, keep in mind the type of carving you’ll be doing, the tools you’ll be using, and the finished product you’re aiming for. With these considerations in mind, you’ll be able to choose the right wood for your project with confidence and ease.

Carving with Different Wood Types

As a wood carver, it is essential to know how to work with different types of wood. Each wood type has unique characteristics that can impact the carving process. In this section, I will discuss the different methods for working with high moisture content wood, high density wood, softest wood, and hardest wood.

Working with High Moisture Content Wood

Green wood or wood with high moisture content can be challenging to work with. It is softer and more pliable than dry wood, which can make it easier to carve. However, it can also be more prone to splitting and warping.

To work with high moisture content wood, I recommend using a sharp knife and carving away from the center of the wood. This technique will help prevent splitting.  When your project is complete, it’s important to allow your piece to dry out slowly and evenly to minimize cracking and warping.  Check out our article on drying green wood, we have tips to help.

Working with High Density Wood

Dense wood, such as oak and maple, can be difficult to carve because it is harder and less pliable than softer woods. However, dense wood is excellent for intricate carvings and designs because it can hold fine details. To work with high density wood, I suggest using a chisel or gouge to remove large sections of wood and a sharp knife for smaller details.

Working with Softest Wood

Soft woods, such as basswood, balsa and pine, are ideal for beginners because they are easy to carve and pretty easy to find. These woods are also great for large projects because they are lightweight and easy to work with. To work with the softest wood, I recommend using a sharp knife and carving with the grain of the wood.

best wood for carving

The best wood for carving may just be in your own backyard!

Working with Hardest Wood

Hardwood, such as ebony, ironwood and teak, is the hardest wood to work with. It is dense, heavy, and difficult to carve, making it unsuitable for beginners. However, hard wood is perfect for creating intricate designs and fine details because it can hold its shape well.

To work with the hardest wood, I suggest using a very sharp chisel or gouge (with patience) to remove large sections of wood and a sharp knife for smaller details. It is also essential to use kiln-dried wood to prevent warping and splitting.

Finishing Your Wood Carving

When it comes to finishing your wood carving, there are a variety of options available to you. The type of finish you choose will depend on personal preference, the type of wood you are working with, and the intended use of the finished product.

Selecting the Right Wood Stain

One popular option for finishing a wood carving is to use a wood stain. A wood stain can enhance the natural beauty of the wood, giving it a richer color and bringing out the fine grain patterns. When selecting a wood stain, it is important to choose one that is compatible with the type of wood you are using. Different woods will absorb stains differently, so it’s a good idea to test a small area first to ensure the desired result.

Personal Preference and Aesthetic Choices

Ultimately, the finish you choose will come down to personal preference and aesthetic choices. Some people prefer a natural, unfinished look, while others prefer a glossy, polished finish.  My personal favorite is to use an oil based finish, like teak oil or tung oil.  They protect the wood nicely while also naturally enhancing the grain and colors of the wood, without covering up the beauty.

It’s important to keep in mind the intended use of the finished product as well. For example, if the carving will be used outdoors, a durable, weather-resistant finish may be necessary.

When selecting a wood finish, it’s also important to consider the Janka hardness of the wood. Some woods are harder than others, and a harder wood may require a different type of finish than a softer wood.

Sourcing Your Wood for Carving

When it comes to sourcing wood for whittling and carving, there are several options available. As someone who has been whittling for years, I have found that some sources are better than others depending on your location and budget.

One option is to visit your local hardware store or home improvement center. Many hardware stores carry a variety of softwoods that are suitable for whittling, such as pine or cedar. These woods are usually sold in construction lumber, small blocks or planks, making them easy to transport and work with. However, keep in mind that the cost of purchasing pre-cut wood from a hardware store can add up quickly.

Another option is to source your wood from downed trees. If you know someone who is taking down a tree on their property, ask if they would be willing to let you take some pieces.  Common domestic trees such as Linden (basswood) or silver maple are great for whittling because they have a tight grain and are easy to carve. Plus, this option is usually free!

If you are willing to spend a little extra money, you can also hire a tree surgeon to cut down a tree for you. This option is ideal if you are looking for a specific type of wood, such as a hardwood like oak or cherry. However, keep in mind that this option can be costly and even more expensive if you also want a mill to further break down the tree.

In North America, basswood is widely accepted as the best wood for whittling and carving. If you are lucky enough to live in an area where basswood trees grow, you can try sourcing your wood directly from nature. However, keep in mind that harvesting wood from the wild requires some knowledge and skill to ensure that you are not damaging the environment or the tree itself.

Overall, there are several options available for sourcing wood for whittling and carving. Whether you choose to purchase pre-cut wood from a hardware store, source your wood from downed trees, or hire a tree surgeon, the most important thing is to find a wood that is suitable for your skill level and project.

What’s Next?

Starting with the right wood is the first step to a successful project, if you’re a beginner, you’d be wise to choose a softwood like basswood, pine or cedar. Learn the craft on cheap and easy to find woods before progressing to more complex projects and wood types. Most importantly, take your time and have fun!

Wood carving is a hobby that is easy to get addicted to, while also providing a creative outlet in your spare time. We have plenty of articles for beginners, from the best tools and kits for beginners, to discussions on how long it takes to learn whittling and making money with your whittling!

2 thoughts on “Best Wood for Carving and Whittling”

  1. I am in the stage of just starting to think I would like to try and learn how to carve. I am not looking for a business, instead, I would like to be able to accomplish something I can pass to my grandchildren to remember me. I would appreciate any and all help and guidance you could provide.
    Thanking you in advance.

    Gary Caputo

    1. Dear Gary,

      It’s great to hear that you are interested in learning how to carve and passing on your creations to your grandchildren. Carving can be a rewarding and fulfilling hobby, and I’m happy to offer you some guidance.

      Firstly, I suggest doing some research on the different types of carving and the tools required for each. You can start with simple projects using basic tools and work your way up as you gain experience and confidence.Spoon carving is a craft i would recommend for a beginner.

      You can also look for instructional videos or online tutorials to get a better understanding of carving techniques. It may be helpful to join carving groups or attend local carving workshops to learn from experienced carvers.

      When it comes to materials, there are a variety of options available depending on the type of carving you are interested in. You can start with inexpensive materials like soft woods or even soapstone, which can be found at craft stores.

      Lastly, don’t forget to have fun and enjoy the process of learning and creating. With time and practice, you will be able to create beautiful pieces that your grandchildren will cherish.

      I wish you the best of luck on your carving journey.

      Sincerely,
      Fisher.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top